The end: Florida must fire Jim McElwain, the sooner the better

With every passing day, the prospect that Florida will have a new football coach next year grows stronger. There’s no exact measure as to how much wiggle room Jim McElwain has left with athletic director Scott Stricklin, but all indications are that his patience for both the on-field performance and off-field shenanigans are dwindling.

That leaves Florida in a particularly troublesome position, one that Jeremy Foley once prophesied only has a single acceptable course of action: “What must be done eventually must be done immediately.”

I don’t care how the semantics play out. I don’t care if it’s billed as a mutual parting of ways, McElwain quitting on his own, a public guillotine drop, or some combination of those routes. I don’t even care if Stricklin publicly remains mum on the subject in the coming days and weeks, and allows McElwain to finish out the year.

But in some form or another, Florida must rid itself of Jim McElwain and have a new football coach in 2018- a new development after today’s ugly 42-7 loss to Georgia that swayed the remainder of McElwain’s supporters with a shred of sanity, however staunch they may have been in their support when they woke up today.

I’m done.

This was the point of no return.

There is literally nothing that Jim McElwain can possibly do to win me back again. And I have a feeling that Scott Stricklin is at this point, too.

No longer is there a rational defense of him and the job he’s done at Florida. In each of McElwain’s three seasons, Florida has suffered four losses, and unless you care to argue that the Gators will win the remainder of their games, they’ll finish with even more this year. That is Zook-ish. Two and a half years of that Zook-ishness was enough for then-AD Jeremy Foley to pull the plug on him mid season after a humiliating loss to Mississippi State, and now, his successor should do the same thing.

This isn’t about the emotion of a lopsided loss to archrival Georgia. This isn’t about the obvious deficiencies of his assistant coaches and coordinators. This isn’t about him running off Will Grier after his PED suspension. This isn’t about him not managing to cobble together a top 100 offense in three years, with six different quarterbacks given significant playing time. This isn’t about his combined 1-8 record against college football heavyweights Alabama, FSU, Michigan and LSU. This isn’t even about the off field mess he created this week by claiming he received death threats and then failing to provide any additional details- although many will say it is.

This is about the sum of all those things coming together and turning this program into an also-ran, a mediocre shell of its former identity as a high flying offensive machine that competed for championships most years, and at the very least showed promise of getting there in the near future in a down year. The goal when hiring McElwain three years ago was to return to that point, and McElwain has done none of the things needed in order to return to that point. Not only has Florida not come close to returning to elite status, they haven’t even taken a single baby step toward it other than taking advantage of abnormally weak SEC Easts in his first two years- and the SEC Title Games Florida got to participate in as a result of doing so proved just how far away they were then and are today.

Now, things are only getting worse, and two and a half years of watching the same movie on loop is sufficient proof that it will never get better.

And so he must go, so that the process needed to get Florida back there can begin in earnest.

8 thoughts on “The end: Florida must fire Jim McElwain, the sooner the better

  1. 1. It’s not zookish. Zook was inconsistent, but still productive and entertaining. At least with Muschamp we could enjoy his freak outs. This is literally worse than Muschamp.

    2. They need to hire a rock star. Not another first time coach who was part of the Saban plug and play turnkey offense. No going on the cheap.

  2. As a former supporter, all I can say at this time is, “Huahh!”. Randy Shannon can take this team through the remainder of this miserable year, there’s at least an OC on the staff somewhere, and we need to get a new coach named before it’s too late. And I don’t mean a Nick Saban disciple, I mean somebody with their own proven credentials in the big leagues.

  3. I think when we all knew this was going to be the case when we trotted out against Michigan and proceeded to score 0 offensive points.

    Absolutely no development of the QB position and streaky O-line play has caused his downfall.

    With that said, we know it’s tome to move on. Question is: who do we pursue? I’m still on the Scott Frost bandwagon but assuming he goes to Nebraska, I guess Chip Kelly is the next call?

    1. Hardcore…..I’m not even sure Frost would go to Nebraska right now, let alone Florida. If he has that much potential, why would he go to a middle-of-the-pack to weak-sister SEC or Big-10 team?

  4. Mr Shulman
    This is a novel approach, fire the coach every 2 3/4 years or not winning the SEC East. That is great recruiting ploy, who new? May be in 20 to 30 years One of the 10 to 30 new coaches will win the SEC East twice. High school students can start their resume to coach the Gators.

    1. Anyone with a functioning mind knows they didn’t “win” the SEC East; they backed in. Georgia is rolling, the way the $$ expected Florida to. UT is going to be looking to make a home run hire. There’s no way Florida could sit on Mac another year. This was year three. His team. It was worse in every way.

  5. I won’t blame him for the Grier situation. Grier popped the PED test that basically no one ever fails and then expected to be guaranteed his job when the suspension was over. No coach would do that.
    Otherwise though it is hard to defend Mac. The points in the article are what they are. Pretty ugly.
    There just better be a plan. Coaching carousels get you nowhere. Ask Tennessee.

  6. Randy Shannon, Nussimer, MacElwain all need to go. Defense has goyten worse, offense worse. Fire them all now and let the assistant O.C. finish the year. Gruden is talking to the Vols! We are in BIG trouble. We need a well proven coach, not a mediocre coach. We are the Gators and play in the SEC! Quit settling.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *